Zhang Fan · Lawyer Home
中文 English

Converting Fraud Proceeds into Virtual Currency: Concealment of Proceeds or Fraud?

A consultation scenario involving transfers of funds and virtual currency exchanges illustrates questions about the nature of the allegations and the review of evidence.

In the consultation room, most clients who helped move money for others, known as “running points,” or handled over-the-counter (OTC) trades begin with almost exactly the same question: “Counsel, I was just buying low and selling high to make a few points on the spread. I don’t even know the people who were defrauded. How did I become an accomplice to fraud?”

The detention notice brought in by the family plainly states “on suspicion of fraud.”

In current criminal practice, virtual currency exchanges, especially OTC trades involving stablecoins such as USDT (Tether), have become a major channel for moving telecom and online fraud proceeds out of the country. Funds are transferred from victims’ accounts through multiple tiers of money-movement accounts, then used by OTC dealers to buy virtual currency and transfer it to anonymous wallets overseas. The entire process often takes only a dozen or so minutes.

When OTC dealers or money-laundering intermediaries are caught, investigators typically first open a case on suspicion of complicity in fraud. For defence counsel, the central question is whether to classify the conduct as fraud or as disguising or concealing criminal proceeds, referred to here as “concealing criminal proceeds.”

The difference between the potential sentences is stark:

  • Fraud involving RMB 500,000 or more qualifies as involving an “especially large amount,” and the custodial sentence usually starts at ten years;
  • If the charge is reduced to concealing criminal proceeds, even in a “serious” case, the statutory custodial range is three to seven years.

The central distinction: Was there “prior collusion” and a “shared criminal intent”?

A finding of complicity in fraud requires proof of a meeting of minds between the person and the upstream fraud group. In other words, had you already become involved while the upstream fraud was being carried out? Did you know the group was defrauding specific victims, and did you promise to help it launder the proceeds?

Suppose the OTC dealer merely spends time in various crypto arbitrage groups and Telegram groups, accepts funds of unknown origin to purchase virtual currency, and earns an exchange spread far above market rates. This amounts to “generalized knowledge” on the dealer’s part: the dealer knows the money is dirty but does not know whether it comes from fraud, theft, embezzlement or running a gambling operation.

Under the criminal law principle that the subjective and objective elements must correspond, providing a means of transferring funds or an exchange service only after the upstream offence is complete, without prior collusion, is a typical downstream offence. It should be assessed as concealing criminal proceeds under Article 312 of the Criminal Law rather than fraud.

Key points to examine in practice:

  1. Timing of interactions in chat records: Review the suspect’s communications with upstream participants to see whether the suspect received fraud scripts in advance or helped coordinate incoming payments in real time, or merely released the virtual currency after receiving a transfer.
  2. Trading prices and settlement methods: Normal OTC margins are usually a few tenths of a percent to around one percent. If the suspect bought USDT at a steep discount of 10% or even 20% below market price, used one-way deletion software, frequently changed wallet addresses, or handed over cold wallets in person, judicial authorities are very likely to infer knowledge from those facts. But was the suspect aware that the funds were the proceeds of someone else’s fraud, or merely aware that the transactions were unusual? Distinguishing these states of mind is central to challenging a fraud allegation.
  3. Evidence of intercepted or retained funds: Check whether any accounts were frozen after victims reported the matter and whether the client voluntarily cooperated with restitution or lodged an appeal with the platform.

Moving the legal assessment from fraud towards concealing criminal proceeds is more than a choice of words. For a young person, it can make the difference between spending two or three years in a detention centre and more than a decade in prison.

Back to Case Analysis

Contact via WeChat

WeChat contact QR code
Scan in WeChat or from saved photos.