Zhang Fan · Lawyer Home
中文 English

Criminal Detention for Scraping 100,000 Product Records: How Can a Lawyer Defend the Case?

Assessing allegations involving web crawling through public access, the method of collection and the nature of the data.

“I wrote the code, but everything it scraped was publicly available prices and titles on public pages. How does that make it a suspected crime?”

When Lao Chen, the head of the technical team, was taken away, a crawler script monitoring competitors’ price fluctuations was still running on his computer screen. The document issued by the public security authorities identified the suspected offense as illegally obtaining data from a computer information system under Article 285, paragraph 2, of the Criminal Law. The investigators’ central factual allegation amounted to a single sentence: using web-crawling technology to illegally obtain more than 100,000 product data records from the target e-commerce platform.

“100,000 records” initially describes the number of records involved. To determine whether the circumstances are “serious” under criminal law, first establish what data was collected, how it was obtained and which criterion in the judicial interpretation applies.

But technology has its own operational logic, and criminal law must adhere to a strict principle of restraint. In defending this type of technology-related offense, the central approach is to examine three underlying factual questions:

First, is the data involved “public data” or “non-public data”?

Article 285 of the Criminal Law was originally intended to protect the security of computer information systems and data privacy. If product names, SKUs, listed prices, and public reviews on the target platform are information that any ordinary internet user can view directly in a browser without registering or logging in, that data is not inherently “confidential.”

Obtaining public data does not infringe the system’s data confidentiality interests. A crawler is essentially a tool for large-scale, high-frequency “copying and pasting.” Treating this as a criminal offense solely because it is more efficient than manual copying would be tantamount to criminalizing the technological tool itself.

Second, did the methods used constitute “intrusion” or the “use of other technical means”?

This is the technical dividing line between criminal and non-criminal conduct.

  • If the crawler did not breach the other party’s firewall, brute-force an encryption algorithm, exploit a system vulnerability, or forge someone else’s Token or Cookie to bypass access authorization checks, and merely simulated a normal user’s HTTP requests, its conduct must not lightly be characterized as “intrusion.”
  • A breach of platform rules can provide a line of inquiry. Criminal liability must also be assessed in light of access permissions, the methods used to obtain the data and the actual consequences.

Third, identify the “nature of the data” under the statutory sentencing criteria.

For the illegal acquisition of identity authentication information, the judicial interpretation distinguishes two categories. Obtaining 10 or more sets of identity authentication information for online financial services, such as payment and settlement or securities trading, can qualify as “serious circumstances.” The threshold for other identity authentication information is 500 sets. These two numerical thresholds do not apply to ordinary product data such as titles and prices. For such data, first examine whether the method of acquisition was unlawful, then verify unlawful proceeds, economic losses and other relevant circumstances. Unlawful proceeds of at least RMB 5,000 or economic losses of at least RMB 10,000 are two of the criteria for “serious circumstances” listed in the judicial interpretation.

If the authorities handling the case directly apply the record-counting logic for “usernames and passwords” to 100,000 publicly available “product titles and prices” and classify the circumstances as especially serious, that is a fundamental error in the application of the law.

Guidance on defense action:

When taking on this type of case, the first priority is to apply to the authorities handling the case for a technical appraisal and a data audit. Establish whether the crawler caused the target server to crash or resulted in excessive bandwidth consumption, to rule out the possibility of the offense of damaging a computer information system under Article 286 of the Criminal Law. Clarify the scraping logic of the code involved and demonstrate that it called only publicly accessible interfaces on the host. Keep the dispute firmly within the boundaries of the Anti-Unfair Competition Law and civil and commercial tort liability, preventing excessive intervention by the criminal justice system.

Back to Case Analysis

Contact via WeChat

WeChat contact QR code
Scan in WeChat or from saved photos.