Zhang Fan · Lawyer Home
中文 English

Detained for Helping Others Unblock Accounts: How Might a Lawyer Approach the Defense?

Distinguish platform rule violations from criminal offenses, and examine account use, knowledge and the links between the evidence.

Behind the barred window of the detention centre’s consultation room, young Xiaolin began crying as soon as he sat down.

“Counsel, I really didn’t know they were using those WeChat accounts for fraud. I took the jobs in a part-time work group. They said their accounts had been flagged after being logged into from another location, and asked me to help with verification to unblock them, or use the card numbers they supplied to receive SMS verification codes. They paid me RMB 30 per job. I only made just over RMB 3,000 in total. How did I become a fraudster?”

This has become an extremely common type of case in criminal practice in recent years. Tempted by small payments of tens or hundreds of yuan, many people take part in so-called “part-time account unblocking” and end up suspected of assisting information network criminal activities under Article 287-2 of the Criminal Law, concealing criminal proceeds, or even complicity in online fraud.

Investigators often approach these cases through a standard chain of reasoning: an unblocked account was used for fraud, victims’ money entered the associated network, and you provided support within that illicit network, so your conduct constitutes a crime.

Defence counsel must look beyond that assembly-line reasoning and focus the defence precisely on the question of knowledge.

The first line of defence: Challenging presumed knowledge and defining what the person actually knew.

When finding knowledge, the authorities often invoke provisions in judicial interpretations concerning inferred knowledge, such as “clearly abnormal transaction prices” or “using covert communications software.”

During file review and client consultations, defence counsel must examine whether those conditions genuinely apply:

  1. Was the payment unusually high? If someone paid RMB 2,000 to unblock one account, that would be far outside ordinary expectations and make a claim of ignorance difficult to explain. But if Xiaolin received only RMB 20 to RMB 30 per job, that falls within common rates for online errands and platform crowdsourcing work, and cannot directly establish that he necessarily knew the account was connected with fraud;
  2. Examine the communications and deception: Carefully review the upstream party’s messages. If that party used fabricated “customer service scripts,” such as “unblocking a gaming account” or “unblocking after an unusual remote check-in,” and deliberately concealed the real purpose, the client may have been deceived and lacked any intention to conspire in the downstream crime;
  3. Consider the person’s knowledge and experience: Students and people who have only recently entered working life cannot be expected to understand illicit online networks to the same extent as professional network technicians or investigators.

The second line of defence: Carefully distinguishing assistance from hacking methods.

In practice, helping to unblock an account can take fundamentally different technical forms:

  • One is ordinary assistance through established procedures. The person uses their real identity details and confirms a request under the platform’s normal “WeChat friend-assisted unblocking” rules. The operation itself is permitted by the platform’s process, although it may breach the user agreement. Breaching a platform agreement does not automatically constitute a criminal offence;
  • The other involves hacking techniques, such as software controlling groups of accounts, credential-stuffing tools, or falsified live facial verification to bypass security mechanisms.

If the client neither developed nor used hacking tools and merely clicked the assistance option through the official channel, defence counsel must firmly distinguish civil violations from criminal offences and prevent ordinary noncompliant assistance from being treated too broadly as a crime.

The third line of defence: Scrutinizing the causal connection with the downstream offence and the amount involved.

In allegations of assisting information network criminal activities or concealing criminal proceeds, the prosecution often attributes the “total amount reported by all victims” associated with the unblocked account to the person.

But the movement of electronic evidence is complex:

  • After being unblocked, was the account actually used to publish fraudulent advertisements, or merely as an ordinary intermediate channel for directing traffic?
  • Does the timing of the account being unblocked correspond to the victims’ fraudulent transfers? There have been cases where victims transferred money three days before an account was unblocked, yet investigators attributed those amounts to the person who unblocked it;
  • Do the transaction records include ordinary business payments or mistaken transfers? Such amounts cannot simply be included together in the criminal amount.

The fourth defence tactic: Presenting defence submissions during the critical period between detention and the review of arrest approval.

During the critical period between detention and the review of arrest approval, defence counsel should promptly examine the facts, evidence and conditions for arrest.

If the available evidence is insufficient to establish complicity in fraud, defence counsel should challenge that allegation. Counsel should also independently examine whether the client knew that another person was using an information network to commit a crime, whether the client provided assistance and whether the conduct meets the standard of “serious circumstances,” before assessing whether the offence of assisting information network criminal activities is established. The absence of a share in the proceeds can be considered when examining the extent of the client’s involvement.

Based on the facts and evidence, counsel should present the applicable arguments that no offence is established, the evidence is insufficient or the conditions for arrest are not met. Where leniency is warranted, counsel should also submit materials concerning the duration of participation, financial benefit, acknowledgment of guilt and remorse, and cooperation with the investigation.

Many young people believe they are merely “helping with a few clicks” until handcuffs reveal the dangers of illicit online networks. Criminal defence is not about excusing crime. Under the weight of state punishment, it is about bringing ordinary people drawn through ignorance to the margins of a criminal chain back within the boundaries that the rule of law should provide.

Back to Legal Guides

Contact via WeChat

WeChat contact QR code
Scan in WeChat or from saved photos.