Case Report | Platform subsidy allegations on a tens-of-millions scale, bail after arrest approval and a suspended sentence: The data puzzle exposed by a “reversal”
Basic case information
| Charge | Fraud |
|---|---|
| Amount involved | The combined value of subsidies and transactions across the case was in the tens of millions of yuan. |
| Stage at which counsel took over | After approval of arrest |
| Outcome | Released on bail after approval of arrest. The court convicted J of fraud and suspended the sentence. |
I. The predicament: A subsidy exploitation storm involving tens of millions and the walls of detention
In recent years, major e-commerce platforms have competed increasingly fiercely for traffic through “Ten-Billion-Yuan Subsidies” campaigns. Alongside that competition has come a strict criminal crackdown on sham transactions and deliberate schemes to obtain substantial platform subsidies improperly.
In this case, a well-known e-commerce platform reported to the authorities after an internal risk-control review. It alleged that a group had exploited loopholes in the rules to obtain platform subsidies on a large scale. The combined value of the subsidies and transactions involved across the case reached tens of millions of yuan. J was drawn into the centre of the storm and placed in criminal detention by the police on suspicion of fraud.
More seriously, by the time J’s family approached lawyer Zhang Fan, the procuratorate had already formally approved J’s arrest.
In a criminal fraud case involving amounts in the tens of millions of yuan, approval of arrest means the authorities have made a preliminary finding that the amount involved is substantial and that the person poses a danger to society. With the detention centre’s high walls closing in, J faced a severe custodial sentence starting at ten years if the defence could not overturn the factual picture through the evidence.
II. Tracing the orders: Following order numbers to uncover entries where subsidies were “paid” and then “reversed”
After taking the case, lawyer Zhang Fan first had to work through the enormous volume of electronic accounting records supplied by the e-commerce platform.
In economic crime cases involving platforms, the prosecution often relies heavily on a “subsidy disbursement summary” exported by the platform itself. Many people regard reports generated by a back-end system from large amounts of data as objective and neutral, and assume the figures involved are beyond dispute. But the aggregate data can hide crucial changes over the course of individual transactions.
Lawyer Zhang Fan did not take the platform’s totals at face value. Counsel used the underlying “order number” as the key and checked thousands upon thousands of entries individually against the platform’s refund transactions and its settlement statements for multiple periods.
The transaction-by-transaction review exposed a hidden and critical flaw in the data.
The platform had expressly included one order in its “first-period subsidy disbursement list” and counted it as a loss attributable to completed fraud. Yet after the buyer initiated a refund, a later platform settlement statement contained a “reversal (a reverse accounting entry)” for the very same order number!
The discovery mattered greatly.
After the refund, the platform’s system had clawed back and offset the subsidy for that order in a later settlement period. The platform had therefore suffered no actual financial loss on that order.
Yet under the authorities’ initial reasoning, the order still appeared at its full amount in the list of losses from fraud, marked as “actually paid in the first period”.
Had the platform actually lost money, or had the accounts simply not been reconciled? How had that subsidy ultimately settled? How much of the amount in the tens of millions shown in the data consisted of similar entries where a payment had been clawed back or a refund followed by a correcting reversal?
III. Going deeper: Checking the rules and cross-checking three kinds of evidence to define the scope of responsibility
With this discrepancy in one order as a starting point, lawyer Zhang Fan promptly expanded the evidentiary challenge and developed the defence on three fronts.
-
Preserving the evidence and requesting a fresh review of the settlement criteria.
The defence team collected screenshots of the two settlement statements showing opposite entries, the refund timeline and the Rules of the Ten-Billion-Yuan Subsidies Campaign in force on the transaction date. It presented them in a comparison table and submitted a written request for review to the authorities. The team asked the platform and the auditors to explain the actual final settlement status of this and similar subsidies and pressed for the exclusion of inaccurate amounts that had already been reversed or offset.
-
Going back to the time of the transaction to examine the subsidy rules in detail.
The conditions for paying a subsidy were set by the platform’s pre-existing rules. Counsel obtained the campaign rules and procedures in force when the transaction took place, explained the role of the platform’s system checks and the point at which the subsidy was paid, and drew a precise legal line between users obtaining discounts through ordinary use of the rules and deliberate fraud carried out through technical means.
-
Cross-checking devices, accounts and funds to challenge allegations made in broad terms.
In a case spanning transactions worth tens of millions of yuan, some related orders had no connection to J. Counsel argued that the account used to place each order, the device login records (IP address or device identifier) and the account that ultimately received the withdrawn funds had to be cross-checked rigorously. Transactions that could not be corroborated through a complete chain of objective evidence could not be attributed to J personally on the basis of a general association with the case.
IV. Breaking the deadlock: Bail after approval of arrest, followed by a suspended sentence pronounced in court
Counsel submitted a written defence opinion to the prosecutor handling the case. It laid out the facts clearly and addressed the flaws in the platform’s data directly.
In light of the detailed records of order reversals and the reconciliation of the accounts, the authorities re-examined the actual financial loss across the case and the true extent of J’s personal involvement. They reassessed the danger J posed to society in substance.
J’s detention came to an end. The procuratorate, having already approved J’s arrest, lawfully arranged J’s release on bail pending proceedings!
Leaving the detention centre restored J’s personal liberty. It also marked the defence’s hardest-won success in its work on the central issues of conviction and sentencing.
The case ultimately went to trial. Counsel built on the factual work done earlier and clearly presented to the court the actual scope of the case once the inflated amounts had been excluded, the extent to which the platform’s actual losses had been reduced, and J’s position and role in the overall activity.
After a full hearing, the court accepted the defence submissions in full and pronounced judgment in accordance with the law.
The court convicted J of fraud and suspended the sentence in accordance with the law.
What began with amounts in the tens of millions and detention following approval of arrest, under the shadow of a severe prison sentence, ended with release on bail and then a suspended sentence. A crisis that had seemed sealed by the platform’s impersonal data was ultimately averted by examining individual orders in detail.
【Case notes】
Criminal cases involving major internet companies and e-commerce platform subsidies involve large volumes of data and require specialist knowledge. Defending people involved in these cases requires looking past “platform data reports” and focusing on three points of practice.
-
Never equate the “total order value” with the “amount obtained by fraud”.
An e-commerce transaction goes through many stages, including payment, dispatch, confirmation of delivery, refund and a further settlement. The platform’s own tables often count only the “disbursement side” and overlook the “refund and reversal side”. It is essential to follow the order number through to the final settlement details and remove amounts the system has automatically offset or reversed from the allegations of completed fraud.
-
Use the rules in force at the time to test whether the conduct was fraudulent in substance.
Many subsidy campaigns have rules that are unclear or even contain loopholes. The defence must obtain the campaign rules in force “at the time” of the transaction and check the eligibility requirements and the platform’s review steps one by one. Whether the platform voluntarily offered a discount under its rules or was misled by fabricated information is the fundamental dividing line between a civil breach and criminal fraud.
-
Guard against “blanket attribution of responsibility” based on online evidence.
Cases involving illicit or grey-market online activity often involve accounts being bought, sold and passed through several hands. Establishing individual responsibility takes more than counting the accounts grouped together in a table. It requires careful verification of the device identifier used to place the order, the network login records and the ultimate destination of the funds. Transactions for which those three elements cannot be fully matched must not be bundled into the allegations against the individual.