Case Report | From RMB 3 million in labour placement fraud allegations to a finding of secondary participation: The “premature” date on a recruitment form and the case for a subordinate role
Basic case information
| Charge | Suspected fraud involving overseas labour placement |
|---|---|
| Client’s role | Employee handling customer reception, registration and document submission |
| Amount involved | Approximately RMB 3 million alleged for the group in the initial investigation |
| Stage at which counsel took over | Court trial stage |
| Outcome | The court found a secondary role and imposed seven years’ imprisonment |
I. The predicament: The overseas employment trap and the prospect of a severe sentence over RMB 3 million
In recent years, the judicial authorities have consistently focused on punishing suspected fraud carried out under the guise of “high-paying work abroad” or “overseas labour placement”. Such cases often affect large numbers of jobseekers with limited means who are eager to work abroad, and have serious consequences for the public.
In this case, the group falsely promised well-paid overseas positions to collect substantial registration fees, placement fees and security deposits. When the funding chain broke and the promises of overseas work fell through, the victims reported the matter one after another and the entire group was apprehended. According to the investigators’ preliminary allegations, the group’s fraud amounted to approximately RMB 3 million.
Under the fraud provisions of Article 266 of China’s Criminal Law, fraud involving public or private property worth RMB 500,000 or more falls into the “particularly huge amount” category. The statutory baseline moves directly into the severe range of ten years or more of fixed-term imprisonment, or life imprisonment.
When the case went to trial, the figure of RMB 3 million weighed heavily on the client, S. In group offences, the prosecution often seeks to attribute the group’s total amount to each person as a whole. Unless the defence could overcome the allegation of “participation throughout and a comparable role”, S faced ten years or more in prison.
Against that backdrop, lawyer Zhang Fan was retained to defend S. The defence had one way forward. At trial, it had to use an objective chain of evidence that could withstand challenge to clarify S’s true position and level of involvement in the joint offence and open a path to a finding of “secondary participation”.
II. The opening: The “premature” date on a recruitment form
To secure a finding of secondary participation, simply insisting that “he was just an employee” would achieve nothing. The defence had to examine every original business record involved in the case for objective evidence.
People involved in labour placement fraud cases are often connected to several stages, including public recruitment, promising positions to jobseekers, collecting fees and signing contracts. Lawyer Zhang Fan placed the recruitment registration forms, labour placement contracts, jobseekers’ payment records and the actual personnel onboarding records for S and others on a single timeline and compared them exhaustively, entry by entry.
While comparing a group of transactions, counsel found a flaw in a particularly misleading piece of evidence in the case file.
A Recruitment Registration Form put forward as evidence that S had taken part in a specific recruitment transaction plainly listed the employee’s name in the field for the person handling it. Yet a comparison with the records of when S signed the employment contract and joined the company showed that the recruitment date written on the form was more than ten days before S had actually started work!
It was a “premature” registration form that defied the objective chronology.
How could someone who had yet to join the company have carried out recruitment and handled the transaction more than ten days earlier? The conflict in dates revealed a crucial fact. The company managed its business records chaotically. Records were often filled in after the fact or filed under other people’s names, and earlier transactions were sometimes assigned to employees who joined later.
That logical flaw, buried beneath the paperwork, gave counsel the first substantial basis to challenge the finding of “participation throughout the entire case from the start”.
III. Looking beneath the surface: Separating “promises made to outsiders” from “internal instructions”
Having found the discrepancy in the recruitment date, lawyer Zhang Fan promptly asked the court to check the original electronic versions of the registration forms and the daily assignment records in the work group chats. The aim was to identify the precise point when S began dealing with the work in substance and to exclude the earlier transactions that predated S’s employment.
Counsel then turned to the central issue of “assessing each person’s role in the joint offence”. Counsel divided the evidence into two groups that could be compared against each other.
-
Evidence of external dealings (who made the decisions and who profited).
Counsel obtained labour contracts signed with outside parties, job advertisements and bank payment confirmations. The evidence clearly showed that the main false promises, including “high pay overseas” and “guaranteed departure”, came from a standard script prepared by the company’s senior leadership. The organisers controlled all decisions about service fees, and all payments from jobseekers went directly into private accounts or pools of funds controlled by those in charge. S had no authority over the core funds at any stage.
-
Evidence of internal dealings (who gave instructions and who followed them).
Counsel obtained the work group’s assignment records, internal approval procedures, payroll records and employment documents. These records confirmed that S carried out support tasks such as receiving clients, recording information and submitting documents under a supervisor’s instructions. S received only fixed base pay and a small amount in ordinary commissions, and never shared in the core proceeds of the fraud. S lacked access to the internal decision-making that would have given him detailed knowledge that the company was fundamentally unable to secure the promised overseas placements.
Lawyer Zhang Fan submitted a clearly structured defence opinion to the court. The allegations of RMB 3 million in fraud required a distinction between the “people who initiated and organised the scheme” and the “employees hired to carry it out”. S had no decision-making authority, no control over the funds and no share of the proceeds distributed at the top. S played only a secondary and supporting role in the joint offence and should be recognised as a secondary participant under the law.
IV. The decision: A finding of secondary participation and a seven-year sentence
At trial, the collegiate panel gave close attention to counsel’s submissions challenging the evidence on the recruitment timing discrepancy, the assignment records and the movement of funds. It examined and accepted those submissions.
The court found that the evidence on record could not establish that S took part in planning the scheme at the top level or pooling its funds. S had followed instructions in carrying out public recruitment, fee collection and other tasks. S’s position and role in the joint offence were significantly below those of the main organisers and planners.
The court ultimately accepted lawyer Zhang Fan’s central defence argument in its written judgment, in accordance with the law.
The court found that S was a secondary participant in the joint offence and was entitled to a lighter or mitigated punishment in accordance with the law. The court sentenced S to seven years’ imprisonment.
With the alleged fraud amounting to approximately RMB 3 million and the threat of a prison term starting at ten years, the court recognised S in open court as a “secondary participant” and imposed a reduced sentence of seven years’ imprisonment. This broke through the original severe sentencing threshold and secured a judgment that gave effect to the leniency available to S under the law.
【Case notes】
In group fraud cases involving many members of the public, recognition as a “secondary participant” often makes the difference between a prison term above or below ten years. Securing that finding in practice calls for making three distinctions.
-
Use “fixed points in time” to exclude transactions the person did not handle.
Groups may operate for a long time and frequently change personnel. Each person’s actual start date and records of handing over responsibilities on departure must be compared carefully with the date of each transaction, the contract signing date and the payment date. For transactions before the person started or after they left, system logs and assignment records must be used to exclude those transactions even when the paperwork bears the person’s name.
-
Examine the substantive distinction between “following a script” and “making decisions”.
Many front-line employees recite a script without knowing what lies behind it. The defence must show that they were not the “creators” of the false promises but the “mouthpiece” for an established process. The absence of authority over pricing, project development and refund decisions is central to establishing a subordinate role.
-
Distinguish “funds handled” from “unlawful proceeds”.
Who ultimately received the money paid by jobseekers is the most direct indicator of a person’s position in the offence. The total amount of the group’s fraud, the amount handled by an employee and the remuneration that employee actually received must be kept distinct. Separating wages and small commissions from the sharing of the main proceeds helps establish in the judge’s assessment that the person was “employed by others and profited little”, consistent with a secondary role.