Zhang Fan · Lawyer Home
中文 English

Case Report | Illegal absorption of public deposits involving RMB 30 million: From detention after approval of arrest to bail during review for prosecution and a suspended sentence

Illustration of ledger sheets, a ruler and a pencil on a slate-blue desk
Illustrative cover image

Basic case information

ChargeIllegal absorption of public deposits
Client’s roleTeam manager at the platform involved in the case
Amount involvedApproximately RMB 30 million across the case
Stage at which counsel took overAfter approval of arrest, during review for prosecution
OutcomeRelease on bail was secured during review for prosecution. The court of first instance imposed 18 months’ imprisonment, suspended for two years.

Taking on the case and the initial difficulty

When lawyer Zhang Fan accepted the engagement, the case had completed the investigation and detention procedures and had just been transferred for review for prosecution. The People’s Procuratorate had already approved Z’s arrest.

The family’s central question at the time was why the arrest was still approved after Z had raised money from several sources and made partial repayments during the investigation.

In economic crime cases involving many members of the public, mid-level team managers often find themselves in a difficult position. The platform involved in this case had taken in nearly RMB 30 million overall. Early in an investigation, the authorities typically focus more on the overall amount and the titles held by those involved. If the evidence does not fully document the repayments or clearly connect them to the relevant part of the case, the authorities may readily request and approve arrest on the grounds that the amount involved is substantial and that the person poses a danger to society.

Defence point one: Checking proof of repayment and addressing the critical timing gap

When the case entered review for prosecution, counsel’s first major task in examining the file was to review comprehensively the financial receipts and disbursements and the records of material transfers in the investigation file.

After comparing the bank confirmations Z held with the authorities’ document receipt records one by one, counsel identified a critical procedural detail.

A confirmation for a significant repayment had actually been issued during the investigation, but the case file recorded receipt and registration of the confirmation after the case had been transferred for review for prosecution.

This gap meant that when investigators requested approval of arrest, the prosecutor reviewing that request did not have this key evidence of reduced losses presented fully and clearly.

Counsel immediately organised the repayment materials systematically.

  1. Setting out the two timelines. For each payment, counsel listed the actual payment date and the date its confirmation was handed over and entered in the file.
  2. Verifying what each payment covered. Counsel checked the receiving accounts and acknowledgements of receipt and linked each payment precisely to the corresponding investors who had suffered losses.
  3. Submitting a dedicated legal opinion. Counsel provided a written explanation to the prosecutor handling the case, arguing that Z had shown clear remorse and acted on it as early as the investigation stage. Counsel argued that Z met the conditions for statutory and discretionary leniency by actively returning proceeds and making repayments before public prosecution was instituted, thereby reducing the harm caused.

Defence point two: Looking beyond the job title to define the team manager’s actual responsibility

Alongside the repayment facts, the other focus of the defence was separating the amount involved across the case from Z’s individual responsibility.

In cases of illegal absorption of public deposits, the title of team manager alone cannot establish that the person is responsible for the entire case amount or for all funds raised by the team. Using appointment documents, business data and correspondence, counsel examined Z’s involvement in separate parts.

  • Tenure and scale of fundraising. Counsel carefully matched Z’s actual start and end dates in the role against the platform’s transaction records and excluded fundraising before Z joined and after Z left.
  • Actual duties. Counsel checked whether Z took part in designing the platform’s top-level plans for misleading publicity and promotion, and whether Z had the power to control the platform’s funds.
  • Personal gains. Counsel examined the composition of Z’s base salary and commissions to establish the actual amount of Z’s unlawful proceeds.

The review showed that the platform had hired Z to carry out routine business management. Z had no dealings with the core pool of funds. The review indicated a lower degree of personal culpability and a subordinate position and role.

Outcome: Achieving the defence objectives in stages

After fully verifying the repayments and reassessing the danger to society, the prosecutor handling the case accepted the defence submissions in accordance with the law. During review for prosecution, the prosecutor changed the compulsory measure applicable to Z to release on bail pending proceedings.

Leaving the detention centre changed Z’s custodial status and also put the defence in a stronger position to seek a sentence that would not require immediate imprisonment at the subsequent trial stage.

When the case went to court, counsel continued with the same defence strategy and presented the court with the timing of the repayments, the objective evidence of reduced harm and Z’s place and role in the joint offence. After hearing the case, the court took account of all the circumstances, Z’s remorse and the reduction in harm through repayments. The court ruled as follows.

Z was convicted of illegal absorption of public deposits and sentenced to 18 months’ imprisonment, suspended for two years.

Case takeaways

In economic crime cases involving many members of the public, defending mid-level employees of the enterprise involved often follows recognisable patterns.

  • Repayment depends on timing and a complete chain of evidence as well as amount. The payment date, the date the proof was entered in the file, the recipient and the investors covered must form a coherent chain of evidence. In particular, establishing that the repayments were made before public prosecution was instituted directly affects the recognition of a statutory ground for leniency.
  • A job title does not determine the sentencing benchmark. Titles such as team manager or supervisor give investigators a starting point for identifying the scope of the case. Determining how much criminal responsibility an individual bears requires examining the actual tenure, amounts raised, control over funds and personal gains.
  • Link the work done at each stage of proceedings. Approval of arrest does not mean a sentence of immediate imprisonment will follow. Organising the evidence to secure a change of compulsory measure to release on bail during review for prosecution is often the most critical procedural step in laying the groundwork for a suspended sentence or exemption from criminal punishment later.
Back to Cases Handled

Contact via WeChat

WeChat contact QR code
Scan in WeChat or from saved photos.